My dog loves these. I try my best not to run out, but it happens. I'v been ordering these for several years.
I first got these in her barkbox when I first adopted my dog. They were her favorite (Pumpkin and honey specifically) from the box. Recently, she developed stomach issues due to her dental treat (which was her mid day treat). So, I decided to order them in bulk and different flavors. I also have another dog now and they both love these. They also love the pumpkin and the carob ones. We will continue to purchase them for their mid day treats (and brushing their teeth).